Would this map be awesome as the author said... Well maybe not but this is defiantly a strong all rounded siege. You should look at the overall score rather than the induvivual scores could as they could have varied eg Balance 3 or Creativity 5 It would have made no difference. For playability this is a strong map. If only... If only you had boiling oil. It would have made the map much better but easier so balance would have to be corrected. For balance it was a safe 4 - perhaps slightly to easy on normal so a better map for beginners. The creativit and map design and I was tempted by a 5. Clever eye candy used - The AI didnt destroy the stairs whcih does sometimes happens. Although it was quite applied perfectly in places. What was nice is the author obviousley put some time into the map and produced some good map design especially with the rivers. Good stuff. For storylien and instruction. The storyline next to the map in teh game was great - a 4 but on the site there was barely anything. I had no idea what the map was like, what level to play on or any storyline... so the mark has to be dropped to 3. A point thrown away in my opinion - 4.0 sounds much better than 3.8. Overall a solid siege, bit too easy but entertaining and a cleverly built castle. Maybe not awesome but some good stuff. Will look forward to more maps in the future. Good Work!