Not a bad first time effort but far too easy - on NORMAL I have played the map twice and the second time it was with 0% losses. I retreated all my men inside the castle so it was far too easy and the first batch of pikemen march all the way round the castle for no reason. They are all killed by archers. You should have had many less defenders and lots of siege equipment for the attackers. For creativity and map design I think 7/10 is about right. The map design looks good and the castle does not exactly look bad - you just could have made it a bit more interesting. I like the forest surrounding the castle. There is not much storyline - just enough for a 3. Overall not a bad first time effort but playtesting must have revealed taht you ahve to do nothing to win the map very easily. Not bad though - good map design - the main problem with the map (balance) is easily correctable.