This is the best of the series so far - good fun to play and definitely the best designed. This map is very playable but it again simple, a map that is fun to play a few times but you can lose interest after a while. Well balanced - you can use different tactics in defence especially with the boiling oil. I can now just about win every time on normal but hard is just too hard. so the map is well balanced but too be honest it is not too hard to balance a map like this. So for playability and balance 7/10 seems about right. The map is creative and well designed - 7/10 here is a better score than in your previosu maps and it is deserved - good looking mountainous landscaping and a good creative idea. I think there could have been more structual work doen on the map - maybe a small wooden fort surrounding the keep would have made the map better. Some buildings other than the keep were necessary in the map. So little storyline - really brings the map down - you really could score higher if only you spent just a bit more time writing a storyline. Overall not a bad effort and quite a fun siegeattle to play - would have been nice to see some sort of fort but overall better work - keep it up!