Well, heres my newest map the is little elevation here as it is mostly forest, the elevations are by your keep as it was built into the hill the iron ore to the north and the mountain that the river begins at in the west. the forest houses many opportunities to contstruct a good village/castle once you get a few trees down and some space to build well it has a good story i feel and i hope you enjoy, well im off to read the rating(s)for my other maps
You've achieved a good balance of wolves and bears to make play interesting, and with the large size of the map, there's lots of potential for building. Interesting tactic of not providing ANY starting goods - I'm not sure if I liked that or not, because while you did set up some woodcutter huts, I wasn't able to actually start doing anything until they came back with their first loads of timber. Still, quite playable, and I was able to get a nice village up and running.
Playability: 4
Balance: 3
Map design was okay, just please use smaller brush strokes on things like the river. The rock bridge was neat. The iron deposits looked much more natural than the stone deposits. I think you have a lot of potential as a designer, just try experimenting with different brush sizes in order to make things appear natural.
Creativity: 3
Map Design: 3
No story, in game or on the description page, but some description of the map itself.
Story/Instructions: 2
Good effort, very playable, could only wish it was more natural looking! Looking forward to more from you!