I'll give it a 4. There's alot of options to do, and i quite enjoyed it. The AI of the enemies was pretty good too.
You were right. On easy, it was really easy. On normal, i couldn't win lol. I'll give it a 3.
A 2. There's nothing special about it. A castle on a hill.
2. It's fairly good. Mix the big rocks, with smaller ones, and it'll look more natural.
I give it a 1. It doesn't explain anything.
The second Siege.
2. Nothing to do really. Quite boring to play. And you couldn't even access the stronghold. And the AI was was surprisingly bad! They go around the castle and regroup at the other side, and they get shot by the archers all the way there.
It is too easy. I give it a 2. Make it harder, or prevent somehow, the army to walk to the other side of the castle.
A stronger point of the map. It's a 3. It's a quite interesting design. But it should have gates to enter the stronghold.
Also a strong point. It deserves a 3. But still, don't place stone so randomly. It doesn't look natural.
Also a 1. It needs a story.
Well, one thing that's pretty much about all you maps is that the messages come to often. i forgot to say by the way, that Rats message on "Rat's siege" map, the "Stay calm, stay calm...", came when the enemies was about to break through the last wall and it looked more i was going to lose.(I didn't though). Be careful when doing a new message.
Anyways, now i've played all your sieges lol. These were the last ones i played for some reason lol. Keep practicing and i'm sure you'll become even better.
OK, now i'll try to mix the two ratings together, into one, hehe.