Playability: 3
Not really fun. I basically sat in my keep waiting for the enemy.
Balance: 3
Too, too easy. This map is marked "Hard". I played it on "Very Hard" and had no trouble beating it.
Creativity: 3
Not much thought went into this map. Generous three.
Map Design: 2
Okay, if you say Amon Sul, make Amon Sul. In the movie, you see the ruins. That gives you the basic design, and in J.R.R. Tolkien's book, "The Silmarillion", Amon Sul is described.
Story/Instructions: 2
Minimal intructions, almost no story.
Additional Comments:Work on it, and put in mini-maps. It helps people see what the map is like.
[Edited on 02/05/06 @ 06:58 PM]
Yoda48
Posted on 02/05/06 @ 09:56 PM
Rating
3.0
Breakdown
Playability
3.0
Balance
2.0
Creativity
3.0
Map Design
4.0
Story/Instructions
3.0
Playability: 3
it was an ok map. i kind added more invasion in the map editor to make it a little more fun.
Balance: 2
very easy. i just sat back and watched the action. once i added more bigger and stronger invasion it was a little more of a challenge.
Creativity: 3
i was gunna give it a 2 but sience im a lor of the rings fan i am gunna give it a 3
Map Design: 4
map was ok, but it could have been better.
Story/Instructions: 3
same as the creativity comment