Back to HeavenGames Welcome to Stronghold Heaven
Downloads Home
Review Guidelines
Main site
Code of Conduct

Advanced Search
Stronghold Crusader: Invasions
New Releases
New Reviews
New Comments

Submit File
Browse Categories
New Files

Download File Post Review Post Comment

The best siege

Author File Description
File Details
Map Size: 300x300 (Medium)
Difficulty: Normal
My first map
AuthorComments & Reviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
Lord Karpathea Kodakeasyshare and artofmath, don't tell him what he did wrong without telling him what he could improve on. The only thing you're doing is blasting him.

[Edited on 06/07/06 @ 10:02 AM]

artofmath (My Opinion)

You should not name the file "The best siege" because there is only one person backing your argument: you.

Even if you disagree, it is my opinion, and I do not care.
kodakeasyshare if you r actually going for the title, the best seige map, ur already out of the running from no info or mini map
Yoda48 Playability: 3
I would say this would be average. Not boring and not exciting, it lies somewhere in the middle.

Balance: 3
Never really played through the whole map. The map disign was horrible. If maps dont look good i really dont bother to play them.

Creativity: 2
This is below average is just a normal siege map for SH Crusader.

Map Design: 1
Uhhhhh..... Wow where do i begin. I know its your first map but you should have tried harder. It looks like you layed down some castle walls amnd some buildings. Next it looked like you just slapped down a bunch of water and grass. not good at all = (. "The Best Siege" would have to be alot better than this. way to plain and needs alot of work.

Story/Instructions 3
I forgot to check if you had 1 so i will just give this a 3. its average.

Additional Comments:
Work on this and it could possible win the title of "The Best Siege"
Lord Karpathea Playability: 3
This map wasn't very exciting, but not boring. Like Yoda said, in the middle.

Balance: 2
Incredibly easy. The "best siege" would make you fight impossible odds. This seige features a small attacking force verses a giant defending force. Even on Very Hard, it's too easy. Narrow down the defenders and increase the attackers or make the attackers stronger. One thing in particular. In this seige, the attacker had minimal to none in seige weapons. The best seige would have that.

Creativity: 2
This was run of the mill. No creative thought was apparent. More on that in the next section.

Map Design: 1
hmm..................There are many problems here, but it's not hopless. Everyone of these can be fixed. For starers, the castle shows no creativity at all, nor does the map it self. for the castle and surrounding "village", it looks very slapped together, very shoddy. You basically put a wall around randomly placed buildings. The terrain was very poorly done. It was grass and water, nothing else. Play around with the editor some, experiment with height editor, make mountains, rock formations, waterfalls, there is so much you can do. But don't have just flat grass and water. That's boring.

Story/Instructions: 2
You need to put more of a description on the web space on this site and on the map. On the map itself, you had a short little story which didn't really explain much. For a good score in this category, you need to put more than just "my first map". Also a mini-map would help draw people in.

Additional Comments:
A basic map. I will regard it as unfinished, because if worked on, it has potential. Don't let a couple of bad reviews get you down, KEEP DESIGNING!!! My first map, I didn't even get one review, so you're luckier than me, which means you'll be able to make this map spectacular. I look forward to your future work.
With regards,
Lord Karpathea

[Edited on 06/07/06 @ 10:00 AM]

Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.8.0

Forum Username:


Create a new account
Forgot password?
Favorites: [Who?]0
Size:727.45 KB