ummm my first map, i spent about 3 hours on it, its a little bit hard becuase you close to the enemy (NOT very close). and if you pick the caliph, Emir, or any muslim faction (except Sultan ,cuz he sucks)...Um please rate, and leave a commnt your ideas will open new doors in my mind...
You did well. But only the story which is very dissapointing. Keep making map! Good luck! This map is good for the beginner.....
[Edited on 04/13/06 @ 08:24 AM]
Lord Karpathea
Posted on 04/13/06 @ 04:27 PM
Rating
3.2
Breakdown
Playability
4.0
Balance
3.0
Creativity
3.0
Map Design
4.0
Story/Instructions
2.0
Before I begin, I would like to say that for a newbie map, this one really surprised me. I'm always a little hesitant about downloading people's "first maps", but this one looked interesting.
Playability: 4
This was a very fun map to play.
Balance: 3
A little too easy for me to win, oh well. The river was easily forded and once I was over, there was nothing my enemy could do.
Creativity: 3
I don't know, just wasn't too original.
Map Design: 4
This was very good, which as I said, for a noob map. This was really nice. Good work.
Story/Instructions: 2
I know people say it's hard to come up with stories for a skirmish, but you could have put something.
Additional Comments:
I am awaiting the next map you turn out with great anticipation. I have a felling you are going to be a good map designer.