This was very easy, despite it being labeled "Impossible". My task force consisted of 150 Macemen, 50 pikemen, 3 trebuchets (i.e. 9 engineers)and 2 tunnelers. After destroying the towers with said trebuchets, I then proceeded to blow a hole in the wall with the tunnelers. This completed, I then charged with my macemen, softening the enemy, losing 27 of them. With the way to the keep clear, I used my pikemen to attack the lord, while my macemen mopped up anyone left. Final score: This castle was too easy.
Seige That! maps are run of the mill. You have to stand out more for a good score.
Map Design: 3
I judge the castle design, not the terrain, since it is not yours. The castle was interesting, but I've seen similar designs before. This one was a notch above the rest though.
Um..........none. Before you say "How can I come up with a story for a Seige That!? It HAS been done, so yes it's possible.
A reasonably average map, but I wouldn't play it more than once, maybe twice.