Playability: 3
It's fun for AI map...but for multiplayer map is not good because UNBALANCE
Balance: 4
like i say in the up
Creativity: 3
The island ok but try to place some stone. And no FLAT PLease
Map Design: 2
like i say in the up
Story/Instructions: 2
not much of story
Additional Comments:
it's good for AI make a new map or update it again >.<
Yasko
Posted on 05/06/06 @ 12:09 PM
Rating
2.6
Breakdown
Playability
3.0
Balance
2.0
Creativity
3.0
Map Design
2.0
Story/Instructions
3.0
Playability: 3
I've rated playability two ways here:
With multiplayer in mind, this map would get a 4 - with all those resources, this map becomes a crazy stone-slinging frenzy. very fun.
With AI skirmish in mind, this map would get a 2 - It's simply too easy. I made it challenging by placing Henry right next to me, and the wolf on the other side of the 'peanut' with an 8000 computer gold advantage. I still was able to beat it in less than 10 crusader years.
So, I combined the scores for a 3
Balance: 2
Simply too much resources. Theres enough stone, iron, wood, and farmland to provide for more than 8 players. Please reduce.
Creativity: 3
Could be a little more polished to make the map look more natural.
Map Design: 2
Again, way too many resources. Choke points are a great way to make gameplay fun, but with only 1 entry point between players, the single chokepoint in the middle is way too narrow. I would either widen it or provide alternative ways to the other side. Also, players can build so close to the choke point, a good player can make it impossible for the enemy to move across it. Maybe placing shoals near the choke point can prevent this.
Story/Instructions: 3
No story provided, but at least give something about the map's gameplay - this would give a score of 4. A great story can get you 5:)
Additional Comments:
This has the potential to be a great map, it just needs a little work. good job.