Playability: 4
This was an excellent map. The two center keeps are at a little bit of a disadvantage but that just makes it more challenging. The only reason I didn't give a 5 for playablility is that I felt there was too much resources available. Too many resources made the map a little too easy.
Balance: 4
The only thing wrong with the balance was the two middle keeps were disadvantaged slightly.
Creativity: 5
Wow!!! This is without out a doubt the coolest idea for a map I've seen. I love it.
Map Design: 5
Once again, the way you actually pulled off the idea was perfect. You are a master
Story/Instructions: 3
This is the one weak point of the map. Instructions are good, but playing it 3 vs 3 was just a tad boring. It works better if the player takes one of the middle keeps and then plays 1 vs 5
Additional Comments:
This is the best map I've played. You have done an excellent job and I enjoyed this map a lot. I know I'll spend way too many hours playing this map in the future. Keep up the great work.
h1_longbowman
Posted on 07/08/06 @ 01:49 PM
Rating
4.4
Breakdown
Playability
4.0
Balance
4.0
Creativity
5.0
Map Design
5.0
Story/Instructions
4.0
Playability: 4
i agree with dcrowley.......not bad playability but some players did hav a disadvantage over some resources
Balance: 4
there appeared a clump of stones for some and too little for others...well it's unbalanced anyway....
Creativity: 5
i liked what u did at the centre.....even while playing the game the minimap browsing thing was pretty cool since it resembeled the earth
Map Design: 5
great job here....authentic piece of work
Story/Instructions: 4
no story....but i dont care
Additional Comments:
cool map.....but a little too marshy
Sirwoodman
Posted on 07/08/06 @ 10:44 PM
Rating
4.6
Breakdown
Playability
5.0
Balance
5.0
Creativity
5.0
Map Design
5.0
Story/Instructions
3.0
Playability: 5
Fantastastic,marvelous i don't have enough words to describe the playability,it totally rocks.
Balance: 5
Fantastic i like unbalanced map,it makes the map difficulty harder.i don't care of the small disavantage for some keeps on the map i make it a challenge instead.
Creativity: 5
Wow i am Impressed by your fantasy,it shows clearly on the map.
Map Design: 5
This map was crafted with love,for the stronghold crusader game.This makes you a skilled mapmaker.
Story/Instructions: 3
it's ok that it is no story,as long as the other things are great.
Additional Comments:
This is a masterpiece,for all who likes to play stronghold crusader well done!.
[Edited on 07/08/06 @ 10:46 PM]
Schlondark
Posted on 07/10/06 @ 10:14 AM
Rating
4.8
Breakdown
Playability
5.0
Balance
5.0
Creativity
5.0
Map Design
5.0
Story/Instructions
4.0
Playability: 5
Centarl positions are harder.
Balance: 5
very balanced
Creativity: 5
Looks awesome
Map Design: 5
Also, looks awesome
Story/Instructions: 4
The other things bring it up.