Playability: 5
Works fine, no bugs, all smooooooth. Nothing else to say really since its all perfect
Balance: 4
Nice balance. Like how you put all the ressources, and trees all as if it really is natural. I find that very fun and attractive as a map to play in. + its harder to make it all balance. Good job.
Creativity + Map Design: 5
Making natural-looking are hard but very rewarding. For creativity and Map design, pat yourself on your back. Good job
Story/Instructions: 3
Well, not much of a story now is there? but its skirmishes, not an invasion, so its still ok.
Additional Comments:
You should try to make invasions. You`ve got excellent design skills! Good job!