I like the castle design alot, unique original. But you could spend a while longer on the terraining, which in my opinion is the most important aspect of the map. Usually the terrain is the part which draws me to downloading a map and it is a tell-tale sign of how much effort was put in. Please leave a good story, it is also an important aspect and will get you better ratings.
I am downloading and I may consider giving it a rating as this is your first map.
[Edited on 10/03/06 @ 06:36 PM]
arhurt File Author
Posted on 10/03/06 @ 07:33 PM
Thank you for your compliments and tips. I have already submitted two more sieges, but can't edit them now. I'll create some background for the sieges and update the files in the near future.
Share your strategy if you manage to siege it :D
And this is indeed my first map. Check out the second one: Castle Whitestone, the scenery there is way better IMHO. I'm pretty proud of the shoreline and the chapel.