Playability - 3 - Everything is available in this map to enable a player to make a large castle or whatever they desire. For me though I found everything was too accessible and space too available meaning I didn't feel challenged nor have to do any real planning, others may find this kind of play more fun than I do of course.
Balance - 3 - I'm really not sure how to judge a Freebuild for Balance so this score is just a reflection of the average score for this map.
Creativity - 3 - Nothing about the map stood out as being above average in creativity.
Map Design - 3 - Nicely done landscaping on the whole, the hills etc looked natural, but the design was unexciting. I found the large areas of stone and iron and the expanse of open farmland a bit boring.
Story - 1 - Unfortunately there was no Story or Instructions included with this map.
Note - the zip file for this map is called maps.zip rather than The_Valley.zip as I would have expected. This could lead to some confusion for downloaders.