This is my first map. It may not be what you think it is but its something and i did good on it i think. Hope you enjoy it feel free to post a comment or rate it. My email is: firstname.lastname@example.org so email me if something goes wrong. =-) Enjoy
Overall, this map was a good one, very nice for a first time map. Balance was good for both attacker and defender.
Map design was poor at best; it's back to the basics. Every thing was flat, grassy plains outside the castle, with a giant splotch of water, and a scattering of trees.
Alter terrain height, use the cliffs/hills tool in the editor, add rock formations, mountains, waterfalls. The presentation is important. The more realistic a map looks, the more people will download it.
Storywise, it was a little short. You have a whole website page here to present your work, so you might as well use it.
For a first time map, it was good. Byt, with some work, it could be a GREAT first map. Remember, no map is perfect the first time around, and thing good requires work. Keep designing!