Playability: 4
I recently saw your map and decided to have a go with it.(called a friend of mine and the connection was established.)I have to say that this map was extremely fun to play it was a total time of about two hours play but my opponent was good.We even played it a second time.The problem was that it was way easy to make a base.An advise from me place the resources (rocks iron) somewhere in the center so the players fight for them.
Balance: 5
The balance of the map was perfect there were no serious bugs there.The fight was in favour of neither so it was fun and challenging.
Creativity: 5
Well I have no serious comments about the creativity everything was as it should be.
Map Design: 4
The map was made pretty well but the river that branches out "Y" looks a bit fake and the terrain around it is sort of unnatural.Also some groups of trees stood out on the map.There are a lot gathered in one location and not a single near them.
Story/Instructions: 2
Well mate there weren't any instructions at all it's a generous 2.Don't let the stroy drag down your score.
Additional Comments:
The map was ver fun to play as if it's soul purpose was to be a multi-map ;) I hope you make a lot more because one needs to relax a bit and leave the siege and invasion 9even if he does fight for dominance in a multi-map)