Playing the map was kinda fun and the limitation of farms made it a bit tougher.It's a three because you only play it from 1066 to 1069 there is too little time and thats why the score was dragged down.
There were a lot of wolves and certanly prooved to be an irritation.Other than that there isn't anything else challenging and thats why I gave you a three.The events were also nice and troubled my expansion.
The map was nicely made for a first one.It looks very peaceful but the space is limmited in two directions and that affects badly on the castle if one is to build a castle.I saw there was a cave written ,turned into a shrine, but I didn't find the cave anywhere just some walls.Also you wrote that this was an eyecnady but I didn't see any either.
Map Design: 3
For a first map it was nice but there were some serious problems.The islands on the south coast all had river springs.And I found that a bit unnatural.I don't think it is impossible but if you were to make rivers from all the small island than make the a bit thinner.Some parts of the terrain were plain and they contradict with the overall mountainous terrain and stood out a bit fake.
Well there wasn't a big story or hints walktroughs they are optional but if you can't think of a story it's best to add them.
In the future spend more time on maps and give everything from you because maps made from boredom won't get you high scores.