Back to HeavenGames Welcome to Stronghold Heaven
Welcome
Downloads Home
Review Guidelines
Main site
Forums
Code of Conduct
Search

Advanced Search
Stronghold: Sieges
Home
New Releases
New Reviews
New Comments
Top-Rated

Submit File
Browse Categories
New Files

Downloads Home » Stronghold: Sieges » Marapal Outpost

Download File Post Review Post Comment

Marapal Outpost

Author File Description
tempkn145
File Details
Map Size: 400x400 (Large)
Difficulty: Hard
Minimap:
Im not lying to you, this is a VERY Hard Map and to tell you how hard it is, I almost lost on easy and its my map i made ._. If you manage to beat it on very hard you are either an alien or a stronghold god.
AuthorComments & Reviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
TibetArmyFreedom Tempkn, (trying not to sound accusing) : do spend any time NOT making maps? I mean its like ur 7th map in 1 week.... but this one looks a bit to hard for me... (no point denying im a noob) desert treasure looks good tho
tempkn145
File Author
well map making gets addicting after making maps for a while >.
Battle Mage corp TibetArmyFreedom there are two ways in which to make maps and both of them are very effectve.The first one that we use is scraping maps that we don't like.Meaning: We make a map and everything but something turns out wrong:Playability,map design etc. So when we upload a map it's usually one good gameplay and map design. The second in tempkn145 case is to upload lots of maps and each and every single one of them will contribute to his skills.If we think of it the second case is even better because people actually tell you what was wrong and how you can correct it.So I don't think any critisism about the number of his maps is needed.

tempkn145, your map looks really good but if you barely beated it on easy than hard and v.hard are impossible to beat.In the future I advise you to playtest the map a lot and set the level the map was designed and the level it should be played.

Lan al Malkier
Lord Karpathea I'm afraid I must disagree. I whole swarm of maps does nothing positive for a player, especially a relativly new designer. I'm assuming you've heard the phrase, "Quality over Quantity"? While it may help his skills, it will give him the reputation of being a "spammer", someone who overloads the downloads section with a slew of average to below average maps. Not a good thing. An experienced designer will focus on one, or maybe two maps at a time, working the bugs out, finding the problems, buffing the rough edges. Not spend a few hours on one map, do that twenty times, and upload them all.
Sulis
Rating
3.0
Breakdown
Playability3.5
Balance4.0
Creativity3.0
Map Design3.0
Story/Instructions1.5
Playability: 3.5
There are no specific instructions to inform the player whether this is to be played as an attacker, defender or both. Therefore, this review is based on both approaches, but assumes that you are laying siege to the castle.

The map is certainly tricky to beat and there are many obstacles to hinder your progress. You aren't just faced with the defending army, but huge pitch ditches and plenty of moat to dig through, leaving your troops open to crossbow fire from pretty much any angle you care to take. Similarly, playing this at very hard difficulty as a defender, and therefore against the full force of the AI, leaves you with plenty to do and the central location means you are never quite sure which side the AI may successfully breach. Back to attacking mode, and you are even restricted to moving large volumes of units around just in case you dare to tread on a pitch ditch (which are easy enough to recognise). A sensible amount of starting gold allows you to build a few siege engines which helps to take down some of the outer defences (towers). The map is certainly playable at different levels of difficulty and can be played as both an attacker and defender. This versatility is one of the map's strong points. A more precise score could be awarded if the player and reviewer could be sure they were playing the map the way the author intended and this lack of basic information and instruction is a bit of a problem.

Balance: 4
The difficulty setting on the download page is indicated as 'hard'. Playing as an attacker on hard setting is certainly a challenge and there are different approaches you can take, depending on your style. However, when the map is dissected you are still faced with a castle cut off from the mainland by moat and probably over-manned too. The game has insufficient realism for me, nor does it contain enough of that fictitious element to justify placing it in either category. The map is definitely difficult on hard setting, but perfectly beatable with careful and considered tactics. Despite the obvious benefits of having a siege map that can be played a number of ways using a variety of tactical approaches, the map still left me feeling a bit cold towards it and it lacked something special, or different. Definitely functional though.

Creativity: 3
A fairly straightforward siege map, when all is said and done. Castle, moat, pitch ditches, defending troops, hot oil engineers... it's all here, and they all do what they're supposed to. The map lacks something though and this is another case of a perfectly well made map, but sadly has little special about it, nothing different to lift it from the majority of siege maps.

Map Design: 3
The premise of a centrally located castle that can be attacked from all sides is always a good one for those looking for a good fight. The whole of the castle defences are put to the test with this style of design and you really don't know how the AI will break through. The castle itself looks fine but lacks anything other than standard features. The landscape and terrain is okay for a siege map but in terms of design it is fairly run-of-the-mill. I have a problem in general with large pitch ditches - I simply don't like them. Smaller, strategically placed tiles are, in my opinion, far better and really get the defending player thinking about when to use them. The outer wall structures seem to act as a sacrificial barrier against siege equipment attacks, but aren't particularly appealing visually.

Story/Instructions: 1.5
The story element is very brief, as are the instructions that refer more to just how hard the map is than anything else. Given the paucity of information provided by the designer, the score must fairly reflect the effort made. The story and instructions desperately need much more content.

Additional Comments:
(none)
The Beany Lord Lord Karpathea you do have a point, but everytime you make a map you improve on your detail and you learn to spend more time in one spot then just jumping all over the map. Although like Karpathea said you dont want to download all your maps at once, like make a map and if you REALLY like it post it up... I'm sure everybody will love it. Well enough of that, this map like darn fun to play (that is if I dont look over every nick and cranny cause then i'll surely die xD)

Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.8.0

Login
Forum Username:


Password:




Create a new account
Forgot password?
Rating
3.0
Breakdown
Playability3.5
Balance4.0
Creativity3.0
Map Design3.0
Story/Instructions1.5
Statistics
Downloads:484
Favorites: [Who?]0
Size:778.20 KB
Added:10/14/07