Yes, a minimap would help. Nonetheless, I downoalded it.
It was... ok. i tried playing in multiple spots, but the castle were very close together which made it diffucult to build.
One side had much stone with little farming space. And vice versa.
Im being generous here. It was okay in this area.
Map Design: 3.5
Not bad. Not good. Try making your maps more realistic. Like don't just put a block of stone and a block of iron for everyone to use. Make it flow nicely. If you read the how-to and help guides in the Mapmaking 101 section of SHH, it really helps you.
Nothing much here.
It was an okay map for a first one. Keep it up. With some work, you could become a great designer. You have potential.