Playability: 5
I experienced good playability in this map. I dont remember seeing any bugs. It was fun to play. The smile of the goblin gives me a mood to play. The cross-sections and ways in and around the goblin's face were designed well. Because of that I experienced good playablity and had fun. Playability is ne of the best aspects of this map
Balance: 4
The balance was good. All the players had equal resources and the map was balanced for teams of two, a factor which I liked. I played on normal and was kind of pleased with balance but things can be made a bit more tough.
Creativity: 4.0
Creativity was ok but more effort can be put in. I think the face of the goblin and other stuff in it add to creativity. Unlike what I thought there were ways through the face of the goblin which was a good thing. The tools in the editor have been used pretty well to make the face of the goblin.
Map Design: 4.5
The map design was, well, ok. While in the minimap there is a goblins face, when playing the map everything looks natural. The resources can be made a bit better laid because the resources although equal lie in straight rows and doesnt look very natural. You could blend iron and stone too.The trees were enough. I was a bit scared in the beginning that the trees might get depleted but I was left with enough trees.
Story/Instructions: 2
The story is the part of the map which I am disappointed in. No story means a straight 1. But I dont feel like giving a 1. Its too low to give. So I think I will give a 2. Write atleast a small story of about 200 words. 200 words isnt as large as it sounds. For example: The face of the goblin. The magical symbol which was created by..................................... and will protect and ......................................................... its landlord ...............
...............................etc.
Additional Comments:
Overall a nice map with good playability. I had lots of fun playing this map. Keep making maps like this!
EDIT:I think the map deserves a little better score.