Playability: 2
As defender i just put all my archers to the stronghold and putted the game speed to 90 and let them shoot the enemys when they just dig up the moat, there was like 6gates so enemy was bugged and there was nothing challengin nor fan at it, as attacker i played in very hard, took archers and everyone in the castle from the cliffs, it is not really fun or playable map.
Balance: 3
it was unbalanced attacking was too easy and defending took time put was not challenging.
Creativity: 1.5
nothing special in the map, just a castle, dig moat, trees and sea in the up corner that's much it.
Map Design: 2
like i said this map needs finishing touches and generally alo more work on it, trees, terrains, rocks, stones, bushes,grass..
Story/Instructions: 1
No story, anywhere, cant give more than one.
Additional Comments:
You just needed to spent more time on the map, playtest it more and it would have been ALOT better, keep it up