Playability: Congratulations for this beautiful map. I found that it was very good. The playability deserves at least a 4 from me for I had loads of fun. Maybe an extension of the river and some oil marshes could make it better? And don't forget to place a signpost next time.
Balance: Hard to judge so I will keep this in line with the other scores. 4
Creativity: I didn't see much creativity actually. The map layout is nice but a bit average. It's a big plain with every resource, just like other maps. Of course I know that free buildplayers like such a maps, but still ... 3
Map design: A very good job, however I have some comments (negative and positive). Let's start with the negatives: a bit more refining could do the map some good. That's all for the negative points. Positive then: I liked the waterfal and the overall layout of the map. Also you succeded in something I like very much and that not much mapmakers can do: You made the map idyllic. I like that very much and that is what I (and I think other players) are looking for in a free build-map. Very good job 4
Story/Instructions: Ayayayayayay, no story, few instructions makes the score go down. To bad, always put instructions and/or a story into your map. It makes it fun for you (score), me (I get to give a higher score) and the players!!!(they have a kick-in). I'll make you a story so you an get a higher score than a 2, which is a shame for such a good map.
Overall: Nice map, if you are looking for a freebuild map then this is certainly a nice adventure!