Have fun with this map. It is my first submission. Also do not rush this map it might require time for inexperienced players to beat. If you know the ropes of this game quite well then never mind the last statement.
Playability: 3.5
(A fun map. I like those siege scenarios)
Balance: 3
(You have too many troops. If you are clever enough to smell the firetraps and avoid them, you simply can storm the castle)
Creativity: 4.5
(Like I said, nice map with challenging traps for any beginner, and I like the first attack so you have to make haste and rearrange your troops under pressure...)
Map Design: 3.5
(Solid. A little bit too bland at some points. The green has been edited with the large terrain tool, as was the stone field)
Story/Instructions: 2
(Too few informations. Try to tell a short story - Perhaps about 5 to 10 sentences. For example, why are there Arabian troops among your own under your command...)
Additional Comments:
Being the 117th to download this map I noticed no single comment. I think it´s always nice to get some feedback at the start. :-)
All in all a good, solid map for a first submission. Liked to play it and kept me buisy for about 45 mins. (Which is OK for a quick game in between) Keep up the work.