La Madeleine val des anges is castles there hung on a hill which dominates the grounds of the south of the kingdom, or begins the grounds of the sanguinary cruel people.
It is imperative that you push back its hordes of barbarians to prevent them from penetrating in our kingdom, if such were the case we would be in difficulty.
Count on the catapults that the king offered to you to strengthen your defense it will be essential for you in the unfolding of the seat. Good luck captain the king counts on you do not disappoint it
Playability: 4
I played this multiple times on defending. I beat it on very hard finally. Much fun. Attacking isnt as simple, and the defending catapults are set to attack the castle for some strange reason (intentional)
Balance: 5
Perfect balance on attacking troops, defending troops, oil on stockpile,
Creativity: 5
Great historical idea with a castle to back it up.
Map Design: 5
The hill is so natural that you have to be on yer toes when defending this great castle.
Story/Instructions: 4
Too light to get a 5 from me on the description page. You get a whole website to present your materials. Use it.
Additional Comments:
Pale Rider says download this great siege post haste!
[Edited on 10/29/06 @ 10:14 PM]
Lord Karpathea
Posted on 10/31/06 @ 10:32 PM
Rating
2.2
Breakdown
Playability
3.0
Balance
2.0
Creativity
2.0
Map Design
2.0
Story/Instructions
2.0
Playability: 3
Well. I tried this map. It was interesting, kind of. But nothing to write home about. It was your average seige map.
Balance: 2
This map posed no difficulty at all. The attacking force even on Very Hard is quite easy to defeat. The ratio of defenders to attackers is just too close. Either cutting down on the defenders or upping the attck force would help. Maybe both. But not "impossible".
Creativity: 2
Like I said before, this was a run-of-the-mill seige map. There was nothing new or exciting about the map, or the short story that was included.
Map Design: 2
This was an area that really needed to be worked on. It was a very poor looking map. The wide open areas with nothing but grass needed......something, ANYthing. Work with the hills some, add a mountain or two, but just grass, a river and a small hill are nothing special. It looks very unrealistic. Add a forest maybe.
Story/Instructions: 2
Short story, not much background, minimal instructions = 2
Additional Comments:
This is not a finished product, but DON'T give up on it. No map is perfect the first time around. Work with it, especially on the balance and design categories. I will definitly download it again once some improvements have been made. Like I said, no map is perfect the first time, you need to keep at it. Good luck and keep designing.
Regards - LK