Yes, a minimap would help. Nonetheless, I downoalded it.
Playability: 3
It was... ok. i tried playing in multiple spots, but the castle were very close together which made it diffucult to build.
Balance: 2.5
One side had much stone with little farming space. And vice versa.
Creativity: 4
Im being generous here. It was okay in this area.
Map Design: 3.5
Not bad. Not good. Try making your maps more realistic. Like don't just put a block of stone and a block of iron for everyone to use. Make it flow nicely. If you read the how-to and help guides in the Mapmaking 101 section of SHH, it really helps you.
Story/Instructions: 1
Nothing much here.
Additional Comments:
It was an okay map for a first one. Keep it up. With some work, you could become a great designer. You have potential.