Playability: 4
The playibility was generally good, though it was a tad too easy (on normal only 6% troop losses) but it because the castle was so well designed I had to do some work to achieve that
Balance: 3.5
As mentioned above defending was quite easy. Attacking was a bit harder, so the balance was generally good.
Creativity: 3.5
Pretty good creativity, I like that you provided the keep with a lot of swordsmen; a different approach.
Map Design: 4
The castle was well designed, as was the map mostly, though I thought you could have landscaped some things a bit better.
Story/Instructions: 3
The story was good, although quite breif and only on a notepad file, not on the actual in-game storyboard, which was disappointing.